The freedom
I thought
I wanted.
At twenty, I thought freedom meant keeping my life open.
I did not know what I was walking away from.
The freedom I imagined
At twenty, I thought freedom meant keeping my life open.
No promises I could not undo. No person whose presence might change my plans. The ability to leave when I wanted, go where I wanted, become someone I had not yet imagined.
Then I met the sailor.
For a week, I lived between the sea and the sky with a man who seemed to know how to inhabit his own life. He worked hard. He laughed easily. He could be fierce without making tenderness seem embarrassing.
With him, I stopped watching myself quite so closely. I laughed without wondering whether I looked beautiful. I could be quiet without feeling I had become boring. He wanted to know what I liked, and waited while I worked it out.
I remember feeling free.
It is strange that I did not recognise the feeling when it came without an escape route.
Keeping every door open
Because when I thought about staying, I thought about everything I might lose. The places I had not been. The people I had not met. The versions of myself I had not yet tried becoming.
I was twenty. He was older. Our lives were complicated, and love did not make those complications disappear. There were sensible reasons to leave.
But beneath them was another reason, one I understand more clearly now.
I was afraid that choosing him would mean closing my life too soon.
I wanted to remain possible.
So I let him go.
There was relief in it. I could make plans without considering anyone else. I could change my mind. Nobody knew where I was supposed to be, and sometimes I liked that enormously.
Freedom’s ordinary hours
I travelled. I met people. I stayed out late in cities where nobody knew me. There were nights I felt exactly as alive as I had hoped to feel. I do not want to rewrite those years as a punishment for leaving him. Some of them were beautiful. Some of them made me.
But there were other nights.
Nights when I came home with a story and nobody I particularly wanted to tell. Mornings beside someone who wanted my body but had very little curiosity about the person living in it. Long stretches in which I could do whatever I wanted, provided I did it alone.
I had imagined freedom so vividly that I had barely considered its ordinary hours.
The airport after the excitement had worn off. The unfamiliar room. Being ill somewhere beautiful. Having nobody to disappoint, but also nobody who would notice that I had gone quiet.
I was still free. I could book another flight. I could leave the man who did not understand me. I could begin again.
For a while, beginning again became my answer to everything.
Becoming good at leaving
I grew good at departure. I knew how to turn disappointment into a plan, how to make leaving sound like courage. Sometimes it was courage. Sometimes I was simply unwilling to remain anywhere long enough to be known beyond the version of myself I had brought with me.
Being free made that easy.
There was always somewhere else to go.
What took longer to admit was that I had started arranging my life around the possibility of escape. Even when nothing was wrong, I wanted to know I could leave. A person could be kind to me and I would still feel uneasy about how much they might come to matter.
I called that independence.
I did not ask why I needed so much distance to feel safe.
The room I mistook for a cage
Years passed before I began to remember the sailor differently.
At first, I remembered the obvious things: his hands, his grin, the boat, the extraordinary light on the water.
Later, I remembered how little effort it had taken to be myself around him.
He had not made me earn his tenderness by being endlessly interesting. He had not needed me to be smaller so he could feel strong. There had been room beside him for my curiosity, my awkwardness, my wanting.
And I had looked at that room and worried it might become a cage.
I cannot know what staying would have meant. He was not a perfect man, and a week at sea is not a life together. Perhaps we would have hurt each other. Perhaps I would have left eventually for reasons more substantial than wanting to keep every door open.
But I no longer let those possibilities settle the question for me.
I know why I left. I know how much importance I gave to the life I might miss. I gave much less thought to the life I was walking away from.
That imbalance is difficult to forgive in myself.
What freedom could have been
I thought having more choices would make me happier. Sometimes it did. At other times, it left me unable to choose anything deeply enough to discover what it could become.
I wanted love, but I wanted it to arrive without asking anything of my freedom. I wanted to be known while keeping the right to disappear. I wanted the comfort of belonging without having to accept that another person’s life would matter alongside my own.
The sailor had offered something I only understood years later: a place where I could put down the effort of always being independent.
At twenty, I did not think I needed that.
Now I remember him when I am tired. When I have been capable all day. When I want someone to notice, without a long explanation, that I would like to be cared for.
I have lived a life. I am glad of much of it. But I am less certain now that leaving made me freer than staying would have.
Sometimes I think I gave up a freedom I could actually feel for one I could only imagine.
And that is what I wish I could tell the girl on the boat.
You can leave. You have every right to leave.
Just do not assume that everything waiting beyond him will offer more room to be yourself than you already have.
What do you miss most?
Choose a thought to explore.
Saved on this browser only. Nothing is sent.Read the original essay · 19 supplied pages
Between sea & sky
I lived on a sailboat for over a week in 2021.
An entire week suspended between the sea and the sky, with nowhere important to be and a man who seemed born with saltwater in his veins.
He was the chef on the boat, a deckhand, a sailor in his own right, and the owner of his own vessel. He was much older than me. Wild. Unashamed. Erotic in a way I had never encountered before. He belonged to the water more convincingly than he belonged to civilisation. I liked that. I remember thinking he wasn't quite a man in the ordinary sense, but some brown creature the Mediterranean had spat onto land for a little while. A sea urchin. A pirate.
View original page · Batch A, photo 1

Fierce and soft
A beautiful, weather-beaten animal who knew how to use his hands, feed people, navigate the ocean, and, as I would discover, love a woman.
He was six feet of long limbs, bright eyes and the most ridiculous, beautiful, boyish grin. A little Tarzan, a creature who seemed to belong more to the ocean than to land. He would hang upside down from the sailboat's rigging like a monkey, laughing, swinging, entirely entertained by the extraordinary business of being alive. Yet those same playful hands were rough and weathered by work, capable of sailing through storms, cooking beautiful meals and working tirelessly beneath the sun. God, the contradiction of him. Until then, I had only known hard men, men who seemed to believe masculinity required the sacrifice of tenderness. But he was both. Fierce and soft. Capable and wonderfully silly. His hands were hard, but his soul was soft as fucking honey. There was something devastatingly erotic about a man so completely at home in himself, so unashamed of his own joy.
View original page · Batch A, photo 2

Dancing in the rain
He had the hands of a man who could weather a storm and the heart of a boy who would still dance in the rain. I am pretty sure the night we got off the boat we did, in fact, dance in the rain now that I think about it.
And I fell head over fucking heels.
I was so young. So confused. So entirely unaware of how much of myself I had never actually inhabited. I had already experienced plenty of [word obscured] by twenty, but I had experienced very little intimacy. There is an enormous difference, and I wish somebody had explained it to me before I began offering my body to people who had no idea what to do with the person living inside it.
View original page · Batch A, photo 5

A different language
And then I met a sailor who seemed determined to teach me an entirely different language.
He did not approach my body as though it were somewhere he needed to arrive, accomplish something and leave. He approached it with curiosity. With patience. With this almost outrageous enthusiasm for the possibility that I might actually enjoy being there. He wanted to know what I liked. What I felt. What made me soften. What made me laugh. What made me forget the world outside the room. My pleasure was not an inconvenient little detail he attended to before returning to his own. It was the centre of his attention. He seemed to derive enormous satisfaction from giving, from discovering, from knowing that the woman beside him was
experiencing something beautiful. I had never known a man could be so interested in what was happening inside a woman.
View original page · Batch A, photo 6

Inside out
And perhaps more importantly, I had never known that I was allowed to be interested in it myself.
Until then, I had been so accustomed to watching myself from the outside. Was I beautiful enough? Was I desirable? Was I doing the right thing? Was he enjoying himself? Was I performing whatever strange choreography I had unconsciously absorbed about what a [word partly obscured] appealing woman was supposed to be? There was very little room left for the rather obvious question of whether I was enjoying myself.
The sailor turned the entire arrangement inside out.
View original page · Batch A, photo 7

Returning to myself
He taught me that [word obscured] could be somewhere I returned to myself rather than somewhere I went to escape myself.
I wonder whether he ever understood what he gave me.
He was not a perfect man.
God, he was broken.
I don't believe in perfect men, and I certainly don't believe that every extraordinary lover is necessarily an extraordinary partner. But there was something about his generosity that stayed with me, something I have spent years trying to understand.
View original page · Batch A, photo 8

A familiar current
I think about that sailor more often than I admit.
And this week, I thought about him again.
Because I met another man who carried something remarkably similar.
The same extraordinary, almost feral aliveness.
The same absence of embarrassment around his own wanting.
The same sense that his affection did not have to pass through a committee of insecurities before it was permitted to reach me.
He was tactile.
Warm.
Almost overwhelming in his presence.
View original page · Batch A, photo 9

The ocean returns
It is funny how life has a way of bringing us back to the very things that first awakened us. Not only did my Italian sailor message me recently, but over one long weekend, two more sailors entered my orbit. One arrived with a gentle eagerness to know me, to take me out, nurture me and discover the woman I am. The other arrived like a fucking lightning bolt - a recognition so immediate, a fire so enormous, that I could have sworn it was love at first sight. And just as quickly as he appeared, he vanished. One offered the possibility of something tender and lasting; the other reminded me how violently alive a single encounter can make you feel. And somewhere between the two, I found myself thinking of that twenty-year-old girl who once fell in love at sea, wondering why the ocean keeps sending its men back to me.
View original page · Batch A, photo 3

Nothing by coincidence
I should also mention my fear of anything ocean-related, even though I'm a watery Cancer sign throughout my chart, my name means the ocean, and I have an immense calling to the same ocean I deeply avoid.
Nothing is by coincidence.
The man I fell in love with this weekend had the same name.
View original page · Batch A, photo 4

Before & becoming
It was like encountering a current I had known years ago on the water.
And I realised something rather beautiful.
There are people who enter our lives and remind us of the person we were before the world taught us to contain ourselves. And there are people who arrive to introduce us to the person we have not yet become.
Perhaps the sailor did both.
View original page · Batch A, photo 10

The first lesson
I have spent years since that love affair studying [word partly obscured]. Psychology. Desire. Trauma. Pleasure. Shame. The unconscious. The strange and often heartbreaking ways human beings attempt to find love through one another's bodies. I have written about the bedroom as a mirror of consciousness, about the difference between being [word partly obscured] experienced and being emotionally intelligent, about the way our earliest relationships can follow us into every bed we enter afterwards. And I sometimes wonder whether the entire
investigation began on that boat. Whether a twenty-year-old girl falling in love with
an Italian pirate was, without knowing it, receiving the first lesson in what would become her life's work.
View original page · Batch B, photo 9

A world opening
I think back to that twenty-year-old girl on the sailboat, falling helplessly in love with a much older Italian man who smelt of the sea and seemed to have been born knowing how to live. She had no idea that one ridiculous week would follow her into adulthood, into her writing, into an entire career studying [word partly obscured] and the unconscious architecture of desire. She simply knew that something inside her had opened, that she had encountered a man whose aliveness made her curious about her own, and that the world suddenly seemed much larger than it had the week before.
View original page · Batch B, photo 2

Making the world larger
And I think that is what I want love to keep doing to me.
Making the world larger.
We spend so much of our existence trying to become somebody, trying to arrive somewhere, trying to make the correct decisions and protect ourselves from the consequences of feeling too much. But I keep returning to those two peculiar words: human being. Being. Actually fucking being. Collecting experiences and allowing them to change us. Being here, in this body, on this extraordinary Earth, with the terrifying privilege of loving people who may alter us forever.
View original page · Batch B, photo 1

More alive
I want us to become more alive.
And I think the people we love can sometimes show us how.
There is another thing I have never understood about modern romance: our peculiar embarrassment around the people who loved us before.
Why are we so determined to pretend that previous lovers were merely mistakes, unfortunate chapters to be erased before the next person arrives? Why must every old love be reduced to a lesson about what went wrong? Why are we uncomfortable admitting that somebody who did not stay might nevertheless have given us something magnificent?
I do not want to erase the sailor I met at 20 nor the one I met this week.
View original page · Batch B, photo 8

Entire libraries
I do not want to pretend that their hands, their generosity, their wildness, their wounded little boy, their extraordinary appetite for life and that ridiculous week at sea did not help make me the woman I am.
They belong to my history.
Not as a man I am still waiting for, but as men who opened a door.
And I hope that when I meet my husband, I will be able to speak about the people who taught me how to love without either of us feeling threatened by their existence. I hope he has stories too. I hope he has loved deeply, made mistakes, been changed, discovered things about himself through other people. I hope he has lived enough to understand that we do not arrive at marriage as untouched pieces of paper.
We arrive as entire libraries.
View original page · Batch B, photo 7

Ravenously alive
I do not give a fuck about body counts anymore.
Nothing will scare me, for I have also lived, fucked and loved.
And I have finally come to understand that the man I marry will not have spent his life waiting untouched for my arrival. Why did I think I had to wait for marriage?
God, I hope he hasn't waited either.
I hope he has been ravenously alive.
I hope he has travelled, desired, made love beneath foreign skies, lost himself in beautiful women, had his heart broken open and discovered entire continents of himself through the bodies and souls of other women. How could I possibly wish for a wild, erotic, insatiably curious man and then resent him for having lived as one?
View original page · Batch B, photo 6

Another person’s aliveness
And I am beginning to understand that you cannot truly adore another person's aliveness while secretly wishing they had been less alive before meeting you.
View original page · Batch B, photo 3

Honouring his history
I want him to have been alive before me.
God, I hope he has been.
I hope there are women who once made him feel as though the Earth had stopped turning. I hope he has known the unbearable beauty of wanting somebody, the peculiar intimacy of learning another person's body, the grief of saying goodbye to someone he genuinely loved. I hope he has been courageous enough to let people change him. I hope there are stories he can tell me about the women who taught him tenderness, the women who challenged his understanding of himself, the women whose love made him a better man. I want to hear them without turning his memories into a competition I was never invited to enter. I do not want to be jealous of the life that made the man I love. I want to honour it.
View original page · Batch B, photo 4

I choose you
Every woman who loved him, every life he lived before mine, every experience that taught him how to become the man standing in front of me. I do not want jealousy to make an enemy of the very experiences that helped create somebody I adore. What an extraordinary honour it would be for two people who have tasted so much of this world to stand before one another, with nothing to conceal and nothing to apologise for, and still say, out of everything I have known, I choose you.
View original page · Batch B, photo 5
